In our first post in the Auto Claim Survival Series, we talked about what to do during an accident — staying calm, making sure everyone is safe, gathering information, and documenting the scene.

But once the dust settles, most drivers find themselves staring at the next question:

“Okay… now do I actually file a claim?”
This is where things can get confusing. Insurance is absolutely meant to protect you when something goes wrong — but that doesn’t necessarily mean every single scratch or dent needs to turn into a claim.
​
Let’s walk through how to think about it.

​First: What Is an Auto Insurance Claim?

An auto insurance claim is simply the process of notifying your insurance company that something happened and that you may need your policy to help cover the costs.

That’s it.

You’re basically saying:

“Hey… something happened to my car and I might need help with this.”

Once a claim is opened, the insurance company investigates what happened, determines coverage, and helps pay for damages if the situation is covered under your policy.

Situations Where You Should File a Claim
​

There are a few situations where filing a claim is almost always the right move.

1. Someone was injured
If anyone is hurt — even if it seems minor — file a claim. Always.

Medical issues can show up hours or even days later. Having the claim documented protects everyone involved.

2. Someone else’s property was damaged
If another vehicle, fence, mailbox, building, or other property was damaged, a claim should usually be filed.

Your liability coverage exists specifically to protect you financially in these situations.
​
3. The damage is significantly higher than your deductible
If repairs are clearly much higher than your deductible, insurance is doing exactly what it’s designed to do — help absorb major financial hits.

If you were in Southeast Wisconsin last night, you probably heard it—the pounding hail, strong winds, and maybe even saw some pretty intense skies.
We’ve already had a couple people reach out  just because they had large hail… anywhere from golf-ball to softball sized. Totally understandable. That’s unsettling.

​But here’s the important part: